The case of the Joyme company in Beijing has demonstrated how quickly a Chinese supplier can appropriate the complete visual identity and product range of its long-term client. Entrepreneurs planning to import goods from China must understand the mechanisms behind such business moves in order to protect their brand and capital. Building a stable supply chain requires detailed knowledge of the Chinese market, legal frameworks, and local manufacturing practices.
Who is behind the Chinese copy of the Swedish giant
When the Joyme department store opened in Beijing, it attracted significant media and customer attention due to its striking similarity to the showrooms of the Swedish giant IKEA. The reason for this identical aesthetic lies in the fact that the project is backed by a former long-term OEM supplier to the Swedish company. OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) represents a model where a Chinese factory manufactures items strictly according to the blueprints and standards of a foreign buyer.
Chinese manufacturers that have worked for global brands for years acquire top-tier expertise, access to quality raw materials, and refined technological processes. The moment a contract is terminated or order volumes are reduced, certain factories decide to leverage existing molds, blueprints, and raw materials. Imagine a factory that has manufactured chairs for a global brand for decades. That factory possesses complete blueprints, trained workers, and established wood procurement channels. Launching its own retail chain with identical products represents a logical business move for them with minimal investment in development.
For entrepreneurs entering into business with China, this example clearly illustrates the mindset of Chinese suppliers. Factories rarely view design as inviolable intellectual property, but rather as a technical task they have successfully mastered. If an importer fails to establish clear legal and business barriers, the factory may become its direct competitor in the market.
| Business Parameter | OEM Collaboration Model | Independent Factory Brand |
|---|---|---|
| Product Development and Design | Provided by the foreign buyer | Utilization of existing buyer blueprints |
| Production Costs | Defined by the manufacturing contract | Lower due to direct sales without intermediaries |
| Quality Control | Handled by the buyer or an external agency | Internal factory quality control |
| Brand Ownership | Belongs to the client / buyer | Belongs to the factory or a local partner |
Risks of cooperating with manufacturers that copy brands
Purchasing goods from Chinese manufacturers that offer copies of famous brands or unauthorizedly use third-party designs carries severe business and legal risks. Many buyers are attracted by exceptionally low prices and the premium appearance of goods, but overlook the consequences that arise when such goods reach customs inspection. Selling industrial design that is not yours constitutes a violation of intellectual property laws across all markets.
Beyond legal consequences, purchasing from suppliers prone to copying introduces unpredictability in quality. A factory that uses third-party designs without permission typically cuts costs wherever possible. Imagine an importer ordering a large batch of office chairs modeled after a well-known European design. If the factory uses cheaper plastic or weaker screws to offer a lower price, the importer will face massive customer complaints and a tarnished market reputation.
Analyze key risk points before entering into arrangements with suppliers offering ready-made design solutions:
- Customs seizure of goods: Authorities may temporarily or permanently confiscate shipments due to patent or trademark infringement.
- Loss of exclusivity: A factory that sold someone else's design to you will sell the exact same product to your direct competitor tomorrow.
- Legal lawsuits by rights holders: The owner of the original design may initiate legal proceedings against your company for damages.
- Lack of warranty: Manufacturers operating in the gray zone rarely accept claims for defective merchandise.
When cooperating with a factory, it is advisable to use the ODM (Original Design Manufacturer) model only if the supplier is willing to sign a contractual exclusivity clause for your target market.
What importers can learn from this case
The case of the takeover of the IKEA store concept demonstrates that production specifications alone do not provide sufficient protection on the global market. If your business strategy is based solely on reselling standard Chinese articles without added value, your position is extremely vulnerable. Any competitor with slightly more capital can find the same factory in China and order an identical product at a lower price.
Successful importers build their own brand and add value through packaging, service, warranty, and local support. Entrepreneurs from countries such as Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, or Montenegro must focus on building recognition among local customers. When a customer trusts your brand, the very fact that the product originates from a Chinese factory becomes secondary.
Implement the following steps to ensure the sustainability of your import business:
- Packaging differentiation: Request custom packaging from the factory featuring your logo, instructions in the local language, and a barcode.
- Design modification: Introduce minor alterations to the product (color, material, functionality) so the item becomes unique.
- Distribution control: Define contractually that the supplier must not sell your specific version of the goods in your target countries.
- After-sales service development: Provide spare parts and prompt service, which Chinese factories cannot directly offer to your end customers.
Investing in your own private label requires higher initial capital, but it protects your company from the direct competitive pressure of Chinese manufacturers in the long run.
Intellectual property protection and contracts with Chinese partners
A common mistake made by domestic entrepreneurs is the belief that Western non-disclosure agreements protect their rights in Asia. Standard NDAs drafted under European or American law carry almost no legal force before Chinese courts. To legally protect your product, it is essential to sign a specific NNN agreement (Non-disclosure, Non-use, Non-circumvention).
An NNN agreement prevents the factory from disclosing your data to third parties, using your blueprints for its own manufacturing, or bypassing you by contacting your customers directly. Drafting this agreement typically costs approximately 500 to 1,500 EUR at specialized law firms; verify exact pricing before engaging legal counsel. This agreement must be written in Chinese, governed by Chinese law, and subject to the jurisdiction of the court located at the headquarters of the Chinese supplier.
| Protection Clause | Standard Western NDA Agreement | Chinese NNN Agreement |
|---|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | Domestic court in the buyer's country | Local People's Court in China |
| Document Language | English or local language | Chinese language (governing version) |
| Non-circumvention Prohibition | Usually not detailed | Strictly defined with contractual penalties |
| Enforceability in China | Extremely difficult or absent | Directly applicable in local courts |
In addition to the NNN agreement, a key step is the timely registration of a trademark in China. China applies a "first-to-file" system, meaning that trademark rights belong to the party that files the application first, not the one that conceived the brand first. If a Chinese factory or a third party registers your brand in China before you do, they can legally prevent you from exporting goods from China under your own name.
How to identify reliable factories in China
Assessing supplier reliability requires comprehensive vetting prior to transferring any advance payment. Production regions in China are often divided into industrial clusters. For example, the city of Foshan in Guangdong province is known for furniture manufacturing, while Jinjiang and Zhejiang are known for textiles and footwear. Familiarity with these regions helps you distinguish true manufacturers from intermediary trading companies more easily.
Before contracting business, request the supplier's Business License (营业执照). Verify the official company name in Chinese, business scope, and registered capital on this license. Trading companies typically list "sales" and "trade" in their business scope, whereas genuine factories list "manufacturing" and "processing". Furthermore, always arrange a factory audit through an independent inspection agency. Engaging an inspector for a one-day factory audit costs approximately 200 to 300 EUR, and it is recommended to check current prices with multiple service providers.
If you plan to import goods falling under regulated categories—such as electronics, toys, cosmetics, or childcare equipment—consult experts regarding specific requirements before contracting business. Ensure the factory holds all necessary certificates and test reports valid in your target market, as a lack of documentation leads to customs clearance blockages.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an NNN agreement and why is it important when importing from China?
An NNN agreement is a specific legal document governed by Chinese law that prevents suppliers from disclosing your business secrets, using your designs, or circumventing you in sales. Unlike Western NDA agreements, an NNN is directly enforceable before Chinese People's Courts.
How do I know whether I am dealing with a genuine factory or a trading company?
Check the supplier's official business license and registered business scope. Genuine factories feature the word "manufacturing" in their license, possess their own production facilities, and typically offer fewer product categories compared to trading companies.
Can I register my brand in China if I only manufacture goods there?
It is highly recommended to register your trademark in China even if you manufacture goods solely for export. China applies the "first-to-file" principle, so registration prevents factories or third parties from blocking the export of your products.
How much does a factory inspection in China approximately cost?
A one-day factory audit or pre-shipment product inspection typically costs approximately 200 to 350 EUR per man-day. Request quotes from several independent inspection agencies and verify current market rates before making a decision.
What should I do if a supplier changes product specifications during manufacturing?
All technical specifications, materials, and permitted tolerances must be precisely defined in the purchase agreement prior to making an advance payment. If pre-shipment inspection reveals deviations, do not release the remaining balance until the factory rectifies the defects.
Want to secure your supply chain and avoid risks when doing business with Chinese manufacturers? Contact our team and schedule a free consultation for secure goods importation.
Supplier Guide
Finding and verifying suppliers
How to systematically find suppliers and check whether they’re truly reliable before you start working together.
How to choose a manufacturer in China
Practical criteria for choosing a factory once you’ve narrowed down your supplier list.
The Most Cost-Effective Way to Buy from China
Compare three buying options - cheap(B2C), cheaper(bulk on Alibaba), and most cost-effective(local factories + China agent).
How to Negotiate with Chinese Suppliers
A practical guide to negotiating with Chinese suppliers, with a focus on preparation, cooperation terms, and getting the right price.
MOQ and hidden import costs
What MOQ means, how to negotiate it, and which additional costs you should plan for before ordering.
Choosing Products to Import from China
Go back to our guides on finding profitable products and learn which regions of China specialize in different product categories.
← Back to Product SelectionCustoms and Import Regulations
Once you've selected a supplier, the next step is understanding HS codes, customs duties, product origin requirements, and the paperwork needed for importing.
Continue to Customs →Back to: ← China Supplier Guides
Back to: ← China Sourcing Hub